Tuesday, September 26, 2017

ENGL 2013: The Bhagavad-Gita

Bhagavad-Gita

The Bhagavad-Gita is a very small part of the immense Hindu epic the Mahabharata. (Basically an epic about a war of succession between two inter-related royal families in India.)

This part, the Gita, concerns Arjuna’s struggles with his dharma – which is a complicated word to translate, but means something like doing and thinking and acting correctly – considering what faces him on the battlefield: the necessity of going to war against his family, his brothers and cousins and uncles.

And yet he can’t refuse to go to war, because he is a warrior – that is his varna, his caste.
Varna is the term for the four broad ranks[1] into which traditional Hindu society is divided. The four varnas are:
·         the Brahmins: priests, teachers and preachers.
·         the Kshatriyas: kings, governors, warriors and soldiers.
·         the Vaishyas: cattle herders, agriculturists, businessmen, artisans[2] and merchants.[3]
·         the Shudras: labourers and service providers. (From Wikipedia)

Thus, fighting is also his dharma.

Thus, he must fight, and he must kill (or attempt to kill) his family. But if he kills his family, he will kill that which he is trying to defend: that which gives his life meaning. 

How can this be right action (dharma), he wonders? Surely if he destroys his family – which will destroy not just these people here, but all of his family, throughout time and eternity – that must be wrong action?

This can’t be what he, as a warrior, should be doing?

At this point, Krishna steps in and explains that this is not what he, Arjuna, a warrior, should occupy himself with.

Your concern should be with action,
Never with an action’s fruits
These should never motivate you
Nor attachment to inaction.

In other words, Krishna tells Arjuna that (as a warrior) the results of his actions, either good or bad, are not and should not be his concern. He is a warrior. That is his varna. His role is to fight. If he strays from that, he introduces chaos into the world.

He also advises Arjuna against inaction, or ahimsa, which is the philosophy that advises us to do nothing, since anything we do brings harm into the world, and thus increases our karmic burden.

(Remember that a goal for some in this religion or this philosophy is to reduce the bad karma we accrue while increasing the good karma, so that we can eventually reach nirvana -- being blown out, released from the wheel of reincarnation.)

Krishna says being attached to the fruits of inaction is just as bad as being attached to fruits of action. We have been created to act -- to fulfill our dharma, or varna -- not to game the system in an attempt to get an early release, as it were.

*** *** ***

The difficult word yoga is also introduced here, when Krishna says “Equanimity is yoga.”

We know yoga, if we know it at all, as a kind of New Age exercise routine.
But in fact it’s a philosophy (and a kind of exercise, yes) with a long history. (Think of Aikido and other Asian self-defense practices – they do have exercise and other values; but they also, very frequently, have philosophies, and even religions, that go along with them. This is true of yoga as well.)

Yoga at its root means discipline – we get the word yoke, like the thing you put on oxen or horses or newlyweds, from the same root.

The purpose of yoga, of the practice of this discipline – which is both physical and spiritual – is moksha. Moksha means to be liberated from rebirth – to be freed from the wheel of reincarnation. Dharma is a path to moksha.

Krishna is telling Arjuna that he must practice yoga, the discipline of his varna.  And he must not do it because he fears punishment or because he wants a reward. He must do it because it is his dharma.

Only those who act this way – without desire or fear – nourish the gods with their sacrifices, Krishna says.

*** *** ***

We can and probably should think about what sort of ethos is being transmitted by Krishna and Arjuna in this exchange. I haven’t discussed the other part of their conversation, where Krishna makes it plain to Arjuna that death – and indeed birth – are both illusions; but that should be part of our consideration as well.



No comments:

Post a Comment